Abstract
- New European telematics & ITS report from SBD - HMI Trends in Europe -
balancing functionality with safety
- Present and future HMI challenges, trends and technologies assessed
- HMI strategies of 16 leading vehicle manufacturers detailed and appraised
- Informed recommendations on the most effective solutions
Consumer demand for sophisticated infotainment systems has forced vehicle
manufacturers to increase the availability in their model ranges of features
such as satellite navigation, integrated telephones and multi-function audio
equipment. Although these features in themselves can make journeys more
pleasurable and time-efficient, the design of their human-machine interface
(HMI) presents a challenge in balancing ease of use with safety.
SBD's new telematics and ITS report, HMI Trends in Europe - balancing
functionality with safety, shows how vehicle manufacturers have adopted a
driver-focused HMI for their embedded systems, clustering the controls on and
around the steering wheel and duplicating information in the instrument
cluster display. While this supports ease of use, it can also present an
increased risk of driver distraction and compromise safety.
The report looks in detail at both generic and specific approaches to HMI
design, detailing current trends in central controllers and touch screens and
looking ahead to future technology, such as gesture recognition and
dual-screen displays. The HMI strategies deployed by 16 of Europe's leading
car manufacturers are also illustrated and appraised.
In its research, SBD identifies those HMI solutions which have the greatest
impact on safety, such as the head-up display systems pioneered in Europe by
BMW and Citroën, and the wider availability of voice recognition control,
a technology which is moving beyond the premium car market to feature in more
high-volume models.
It cautions, however, that achieving the right balance between the
functionality motorists expect and safety will become increasingly difficult
and that none of the present or future HMI strategies will achieve significant
improvements. It recommends the development of workload management systems,
which restrict the information provided to the driver and the functions that
can be accessed, according to driving conditions, as offering the best
potential.
While manufacturers can focus on the HMI of their embedded systems, SBD
acknowledges the limited scope they have to ensure safe driver operation of
portable devices, such as telephones and digital music players. These issues
together with the technical integration challenges are fully explored in SBD's
recent report entitled "Portable device integration ~ strategies for the
automotive industry".
Table of Contents
1. Executive summary
- 1.1 Introduction
- 1.2 Conclusions and recommendations
- 1.3 Summary of key points
- 1.3.1. Information moving closer to the driver
- 1.3.2. HMI giving drivers more control
- 1.3.3. Safety becoming increasingly important
2. Vehicle manufacturers' HMI strategies
- 2.1 Alfa Romeo
- 2.1.1. Overview of HMI strategy
- 2.1.2. Blue&Me
- 2.1.3. Connect display
- 2.2 Audi
- 2.2.1. Overview of HMI strategy
- 2.2.2. Multi Media Interface
- 2.2.3. Driver Information Systems
- 2.2.4. Destination entry via voice
- 2.3 BMW
- 2.3.1. Overview of HMI strategy
- 2.3.2. iDrive controller
- 2.3.3. Colour display
- 2.3.4. Head-Up Display
- 2.4 Ford
- 2.4.1. Overview of HMI strategy
- 2.4.2. HMI concept
- 2.4.3. Touch screen
- 2.5 Honda
- 2.5.1. Overview of HMI strategy
- 2.5.2. Central controller
- 2.5.3. Steering wheel controls
- 2.6 Jaguar
- 2.6.1. Overview of HMI strategy
- 2.6.2. Touch screen
- 2.6.3. Voice recognition
- 2.7 Lexus
- 2.7.1. Overview of HMI strategy
- 2.7.2. Touch screen
- 2.7.3. Voice Command
- 2.8 Mercedes-Benz
- 2.8.1. Overview of HMI strategy
- 2.8.2. Instrument Cluster Display and Steering Wheel Controls
- 2.8.3. COMAND Display and Controller
- 2.9 Nissan
- 2.9.1. Overview of HMI strategy
- 2.9.2. N-FORM system
- 2.9.3. Voice recognition
- 2.10 Opel
- 2.10.1. Overview of HMI strategy
- 2.10.2. Central controller
- 2.10.3. Display fitment
- 2.10.4. Voice recognition
- 2.11 PSA
- 2.11.1. Overview of HMI strategy
- 2.11.2. Head-Up Display
- 2.11.3. Steering wheel controls
- 2.11.4. Text-To-Speech
- 2.12 Renault
- 2.12.1. Overview of HMI strategy
- 2.12.2. Carminat navigation system
- 2.12.3. Steering wheel controls
- 2.13 Saab
- 2.13.1. Overview of HMI strategy
- 2.13.2. Night Panel
- 2.13.3. Saab Information Display
- 2.14 Toyota
- 2.14.1. Overview of HMI strategy
- 2.14.2. Touch screen
- 2.14.3. Steering wheel controls
- 2.15 Volkswagen
- 2.15.1. Overview of HMI strategy
- 2.15.2. Bluetooth telephone keypad
- 2.15.3. Menu-based instrument cluster display
- 2.16 Volvo
- 2.16.1. Overview of HMI strategy
- 2.16.2. Navigation HMI
3. Future HMI technologies
- 3.1 Next generation input solutions
- 3.1.1. Gesture recognition
- 3.1.2. Line-of-sight operated switches
- 3.1.3. Finger writing recognition
- 3.1.4. Virtual keyboards
- 3.1.5. Touch-sensitive tracks
- 3.1.6. Fabric controls
- 3.2 Next generation output solutions
- 3.2.1. Organic Light-Emitting Displays
- 3.2.2. Dual-view displays
4. Strategies towards safer HMI
- 4.1 Introduction
- 4.2 Strategies used to create a more driver focussed HMI
- 4.2.1. Simple tasks often done whilst driving
- 4.2.2. Difficult tasks sometimes done whilst driving
- 4.2.3. Difficult tasks rarely done whilst driving
- 4.3 Workload management systems
- 4.3.1. Saab Dialogue Manager
- 4.3.2. Volvo IDIS (Intelligent Driver Information System)
- 4.3.3. Motorola Polite Phone
- 4.3.4. Motorola Driver Advocate
- 4.3.5. Future opportunities to make HMI safer